I cannot remember when my mom started making stuffed peppers, but they have become a staple at all holiday appetizer tables in our family. They are so popular that when my mom came to visit me through the years, we would stop at Whole Foods, get the ingredients and there would be a jar in the fridge before she left.
When Jeromy and I started hosting Thanksgiving a few years ago, I knew I had to make these. Given TSA regulations, my mom could not just carry a couple of jars on the plane with her because of the oil and vinegar. If I didn’t make them, we wouldn’t have them on Thanksgiving. You have no idea yet how unacceptable that would have been.
These are so easy and delicious. The hardest part? Waiting one to two weeks to eat them!
Mom’s Stuffed Peppers
Ingredients
- Whole cherry peppers—I bought about 28 in 4 jars {I had to go to four stores to find them!!}
- 1/3 lb. thinly sliced prosciutto
- 1/3 lb. thinly sliced provolone
- 3-4 cloves of garlic
- olive oil
- balsamic vinegar
Method
First it is advisable to use some food grade gloves for this project. You don’t want to handle the peppers and then accidentally touch your eye! Or a baby, that would not be fun. We keep a box of these gloves in our kitchen and they’re great for handling raw meat, poultry, fish or spicy peppers.
Drain all of the peppers and cut off the tops. Reserve the tops, do not discard.
Some of the peppers won’t be usable if they have holes in them or are a little brown, set them aside with the tops.
Using a melon baller, remove the seeds and ribs, taking care not to split open the pepper.
Next, trim the pepper from around the stem. Discard the stem.
Mince the pepper tops and any cleaned peppers that can’t be stuffed, with the garlic. Place 3/4 of this mixture in the bottom of a mason jar. Ordinarily I would just use the jar the peppers came in but since I had to buy four small jars it was easier to put them into one large jar.
Lay out two pieces of prosciutto end to end and place two pieces of provolone on top. Repeat once, then roll tightly.
Slice into 1 inch or so pieces that can be stuffed into the peppers.
Carefully, stuff the peppers. Repeat these steps until all of the peppers are stuffed.
Some will stick out above the top of the pepper, that’s totally fine.
Others will fit pretty well.
Put all of the stuffed peppers in the mason jar on top of the minced peppers and garlic.
Top with the remaining minced peppers and garlic.
Fill the jar halfway with olive oil then the rest of the way with balsamic vinegar. Give it a good shake and stick it in the refrigerator.
Every couple of days, pull the jar out of the refrigerator, let it come to room temperature, give it another shake them put it back in the refrigerator upside down. The next time, put it back in right side up. After one week, they’ll taste good, after two weeks, they’ll taste great!
To serve, cut the peppers in half. If you have a high tolerance for spicy, use the olive oil vinegar mixture as a salad dressing. I can’t handle that, but my mom can.
Only three days until we can pop open that jar!
Enjoy!
{ 3 comments }



